Tour de France crash and concussion cases expose limits of roadside checks
Three of the eight riders who have abandoned the Tour de France in the opening week have suffered concussions. As happens every year, crashes have
Three of the eight riders who have abandoned the Tour de France in the opening week have suffered concussions. As happens every year, crashes have punctuated the opening week of the Tour de France, with several incidents highlighting how difficult it remains to manage concussion in a sport where the clock is always ticking. Of the eight riders who have abandoned the race since it began in Barcelona, Spain, on July 4, three withdrew because of concussion: Frenchman Clement Berthet of Groupama-FDJ United, Dutch rider Alex Molenaar of Caja Rural-Seguros RGA and Norway’s Torstein Traeen of Uno-X Mobility, who briefly wore the yellow jersey. All three had one thing in common: they crashed, completed the stage and then withdrew later that evening once the diagnosis had been made. Berthet went down heavily during the opening team time trial, Molenaar crashed 5km (3 miles) from the finish of stage five, while Traeen hit the ground the following day on the descent of the Col du Tourmalet while wearing the race leader’s yellow jersey.
“It is never very satisfactory for us to see riders diagnosed with concussion after they have resumed racing,” Xavier Bigard, medical director of the International Cycling Union (UCI), told the Reuters news agency. The UCI introduced a concussion protocol at the start of the 2021 season. A year earlier, French rider Romain Bardet had covered almost 90km (56 miles) despite suffering concussion in a crash at more than 60km/h (37mph). “We have come a long way,” said Bigard, who began working on a protocol after joining the UCI in 2018. Under the current procedure, a rider who crashes must be assessed by the first person to reach them, often a mechanic from their team. If that person detects at least two observable signs of concussion – such as nausea, head or neck pain, weakness in the limbs, disorientation or impaired balance – the rider must be taken out of the race. If not, the rider may continue before undergoing a further assessment during the race from the medical car or a team vehicle.
That examination involves answering a number of relatively simple questions about the context of the race, and the rider may still be withdrawn. Where concussion is suspected, a more complete examination lasting about 10 minutes must then be carried out after the stage. “The roadside protocol is much shorter,” said Mathieu Le Strat, medical director of Groupama-FDJ United. “It is carried out in the heat of the moment, so it is much harder to make an assessment. “You have a rider who is caught up in the race and immediately wants to get back on the bike, so it is not easy. “A proper concussion protocol takes 10 to 15 minutes and involves several tests. You cannot do that on the side of the road.” Florence Pommerie, the Tour de France’s chief doctor since 2010, also stressed how difficult concussion can be to diagnose. “You cannot see it,” she said. “There is no single defining sign, only a combination of indicators.” Pommerie added that she had not seen any of the three riders in question come back to the medical car after their respective crashes.
The BriefWire