A rift in the U.S.-Israel special relationship
(This article is part of the View From India newsletter curated by The Hindu’s foreign affairs experts. To get the newsletter in your inbox every
(This article is part of the View From India newsletter curated by The Hindu’s foreign affairs experts. To get the newsletter in your inbox every Monday, subscribe here.) “Donald J. Trump is the only head of state in the entire world who is sympathetic to the nation of Israel at this moment in time,” U.S. Vice President J.D. Vance said on June 18 in an unusual direct rebuke to the Israeli critics of the U.S.-Iran memorandum of understanding. “If I was in the cabinet of the Israeli government, I might not be attacking the only powerful ally that I have anywhere left in the entire world,” he said, adding: “The other thing that I would say is that over the last three months, two-thirds of the defensive weapons that have protected your homeland have been built by American hands and paid for by American tax dollars.” In an interview, Mr. Vance, who had reportedly opposed the U.S.-led war on Iran, said Israel “cannot kill its way out of every security challenge” it is facing. In a different podcast, he criticised Israeli advocates for conflating criticism of the state of Israel to antisemitism. “If everything is Jew-hatred, then nothing is Jew-hatred,” he said. In the same interview, he said President Trump has “some disagreements” with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on how to bring the war to an end. “They’re a good partner in the same way that the United Kingdom or France are good partners -- that doesn’t mean that we’re always going to have aligned interests,” he added. Trump was more measured in his criticism, but, while speaking to reporters in France, he also raised some uncomfortable questions about Israel’s conduct of the war in Lebanon.
“You don’t have to knock down an apartment house every time you’re looking for somebody,” Mr. Trump said about Israeli attacks on Lebanon’s civilian areas. “There are a lot of people in those apartment houses. And they’re not all Hezbollah.” He also said Israel was fighting Hezbollah “too long” and “too many people have been killed”. In the recent past, Axios had reported that Trump had angry phone calls with Mr. Netanyahu in which he used expletives to slam Israel’s bombing of Lebanon. The public criticisms from America’s top leadership about its “special ally” point to a growing rift between the two countries over the Iran question. And the criticism became public only after the MoU was reached between the U.S. and Iran on June 15. The main reason for the rift is the disagreement between Mr. Trump and Mr. Netanyahu on how to end the war on Iran. Israel would not prefer a diplomatic settlement that would lift sanctions on Iran and leave the country conventionally more powerful in West Asia. But the U.S., having failed to meet its objectives through 40 days of bombing, wants to end the conflict, remove the bottleneck in the Strait of Hormuz that has held the global economy for ransom, and address the nuclear question diplomatically. There are three important factors that are driving this rift. The first is public opinion in America. The war on Iran is unpopular in the U.S. and the economic costs of the war are rising. Mi-term primaries will begin shortly and Mr. Trump wants to extricate himself from the war at the soonest. In the U.S., the public opinion about Israel is also undergoing a transformation. According to a February Gallup poll, for the first time in over two decades, Americans are no longer more sympathetic towards Israelis than Palestinians: 41% Americans now sympathise with Palestinians, while 36% sympathise with Israelis.
The BriefWire