How TikTok-style videos keep human brains hooked on content
TikTok, Instagram and YouTube clips are designed to overwhelm the brain's pleasure circuitry and keep people watching. Researchers say short-form videos may only be the
TikTok, Instagram and YouTube clips are designed to overwhelm the brain's pleasure circuitry and keep people watching. Researchers say short-form videos may only be the start when it comes to harvesting human attention. For many of us, the day often starts with a swipe. Before getting out of bed, we might scroll through TikTok, Instagram Reels or YouTube Shorts. A few clips become a few dozen. Minutes become an hour. Then, later in the day, we return for more. Researchers at Germany's University of Bayreuth examined the phenomenon, especially in children and adolescents. The review, published in the journal European Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, analyzed 42 studies involving nearly 30,000 participants, most of them adolescents and young adults. Importantly, the authors examined something often overlooked in public debate: The mechanics of the platforms themselves. Far from TV on a smaller screen The researchers identified three features common to short-form video platforms: The personalization of algorithms, the unpredictability of the infinite scroll and the novelty of rapidly switching among videos. These features create a media environment unlike television, traditional online video or older social networks, they say. Short-form video platforms work differently. Algorithms continuously select content, users rarely need to make decisions and there is effectively no natural stopping point. "TikTok is fundamentally different from television," Aza Raskin, co-founder of the Center for Humane Technology, told DW. "On the other side of a TikTok screen is a massive supercomputer pointed directly at your brain. It is trained on the behavior of 3 billion other human primates." "The attention economy is essentially a race to the bottom of the brainstem," Raskin said. "If TikTok doesn't occupy your time, Facebook, Instagram or another platform will." "This triggers a ruthless knife fight for human attention," he added.
How dangerous are TikTok & Co. for democracy? To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video The hit and miss of dopamine Scientists have long understood that highly rewarding experiences activate the brain's reward system. Short-form videos (SFVs) are especially effective at exploiting that system. Anna Lembke, associate professor of psychiatry at Stanford University School of Medicine and author of the book Dopamine Nation, told DW that SFVs combined several features that make them unusually compelling. "Moving images are themselves like catnip for the mammalian brain," she said. "Short-form videos are a more potent form, and hence more addictive, leading to video chaining, akin to chain-smoking,' wherein once we begin it's hard to stop, even when we want to." Over-stimulating the brain's reward system with highly rewarding unnatural triggers like gambling and binge-eating causes a flood of dopamine, the brain's reward and pleasure neurotransmitter. To protect itself, the brain "downregulates," with cells decreasing the number of dopamine receptors needed to experience pleasure. Repeated hyperstimulation can, over time, make the brain less sensitive to reward. "We need more videos over time, not to get high, but just to feel normal," she said. "And we lose our ability to engage in and take joy in other, more modest rewards, like watching a sunset, sharing a meal with friends, or reading a good book." According to Lembke, the endless nature of modern feeds may gradually change how that reward system responds: "Endless scrolling leads to reward desensitization, that is, less dopamine being released over time in response to similar rewards, such that more videos with more extreme content are needed to get the same effect." The result can be a paradox familiar to many users: Continuing to search for the next rewarding clip even when the experience itself is no longer particularly enjoyable.
